Is Charitable Giving in Crisis? How Non-Profits Can Fight Back and Thrive

In the face of declining donations and shifting donor demographics, non-profits are facing an uphill battle. The recently released Giving USA report for 2023 paints a stark picture of the challenges ahead. But fear not – there are strategies to weather this storm and come out stronger. Let’s dive into the hard truths and explore battle-tested solutions to help your organization not just survive, but thrive in this new reality.

The Current State of Charitable Giving

The Giving USA report reveals that charitable giving dropped 2.1% in 2023 after adjusting for inflation. This decline continues a trend we’ve seen in recent years, with individual giving taking the biggest hit. Here are some key points:

  1. Individual giving dropped 2.4% in 2023.
  2. The share of overall giving from individual donors declined slightly from 67.4% in 2022 to 67.2% in 2023.
  3. Foundations now account for 19% of overall giving ($103.5 billion), bequests for 8% ($42.7 billion), and corporations for 7%.

Understanding the Factors at Play

Several factors contribute to these trends:

  1. Economic Uncertainty: Inflation and personal economic situations have caused many donors to pull back.
  2. Changing Donor Demographics: The decline in the number of Americans who give has been a concern for years.
  3. Shift in Giving Patterns: High-net-worth individuals are playing an increasingly significant role in philanthropy.

Solutions for Non-Profits

Despite these challenges, there are several strategies non-profits can employ to adapt and thrive:

  1. Diversify Outreach Channels

While direct mail remains a crucial tool, it’s essential to create a multi-channel approach:

  • Direct Mail: Personalize mailings, tell compelling stories, and clearly communicate their gifts impact.
  • Digital Marketing: Utilize email campaigns, social media, and targeted online marketing to your best prospects.
  • SMS Marketing: Implement text-to-give campaigns and send timely updates to supporters.
  • Events: Host events, online fundraisers, webinars, and virtual tours to engage donors both in-person and remotely.
  1. Focus on Donor Retention

It can’t be overstated that it’s more cost-effective to retain existing donors than to acquire new ones:

  • Implement a robust stewardship program with touch points throughout the year.
  • Provide regular updates on how donations are making a difference.
  • Offer multiple giving options, including monthly recurring donations.
  1. Engage Younger Donors

Millennials and Gen Z are becoming increasingly important in the philanthropic landscape:

  • Utilize social media and peer-to-peer fundraising platforms.
  • Highlight opportunities for hands-on involvement and volunteering.
  • Emphasize transparency and demonstrate clear impact.
  1. Leverage Data and Technology

Use data analytics to better understand your donors and tailor your outreach:

  • Implement a robust CRM system to track donor interactions and preferences.
  • Use predictive modeling to identify potential major donors.
  • Personalize communications based on donor behavior and interests.
  1. Cultivate Major Donors

Given the increasing role of high-net-worth individuals in philanthropy:

  • Develop a dedicated major gifts program.
  • Offer personalized engagement opportunities and recognition.
  • Consider creating a giving circle or donor-advised fund option.
  1. Emphasize Impact and Transparency

In times of economic uncertainty, donors want to know their contributions are making a difference:

  • Provide clear, measurable outcomes of your programs.
  • Use storytelling to bring your mission to life.
  • Be transparent about your organization’s finances and operations.
  1. Explore Corporate Partnerships

With corporate giving holding steady, there may be opportunities to engage businesses:

  • Develop cause marketing campaigns with aligned businesses.
  • Offer employee giving and volunteering programs.
  • Create sponsorship opportunities for events and programs.


While the current trends in charitable giving present challenges, they also offer opportunities for non-profits to innovate and strengthen their relationships with donors. By diversifying outreach channels, focusing on retention, engaging younger donors, leveraging technology, cultivating major gifts, emphasizing impact, and exploring corporate partnerships, organizations can position themselves for success in this new philanthropic landscape.

Remember, the key is to remain adaptable and responsive to your donors’ needs and preferences. By doing so, you’ll not only weather the current challenges but emerge stronger and more resilient for the future.

Related Posts

The one letter they will keep

The one letter they will keep

"When donors say, “the acknowledgement IS the recognition”, they are making a profound statement about what matters in their relationships with not-for-profits.”~Penelope Burk Like you, I recently compiled the financial information from 2022 needed for filing my...